Why Did Your Auto Insurance Increase in 2023? 9 Reasons. And Why To Expect The Same in 2024.

Bryan Gutowsky • January 2, 2024

Why Did Your Auto Insurance Increase in 2023? 9 Reasons (And Why It’s Likely Going Up Again in 2024)

If you noticed a jump in your auto insurance rates in 2023, you’re not alone. Millions of drivers across the U.S. have seen their premiums increase, and unfortunately, this trend isn’t slowing down in 2024.


But why are auto insurance rates rising? And is there anything you can do about it? In this article, we’ll break down 9 key reasons behind these rate hikes and what they mean for drivers moving forward.


1. More Vehicles on the Road

As life has returned to normal post-pandemic, traffic congestion has increased. More vehicles on the road mean a higher likelihood of accidents, leading to more claims for insurance companies to pay out. This increased risk results in higher premiums for all drivers.


2. Distracted Driving

Smartphones, in-car entertainment, and other distractions continue to cause more accidents than ever before. The rise in distracted driving incidents has forced insurers to raise rates to compensate for the growing number of claims.


3. A Driver Shortage and More Younger Drivers Being Hired

The commercial driving industry, including trucking and rideshare services, has faced a labor shortage. To fill the gap, companies have hired younger, less experienced drivers, who statistically get into more accidents. This has increased insurance costs not just for commercial vehicles but also for personal auto insurance as insurers adjust their overall risk models.


4. Increased Accident Severity

Accidents aren’t just happening more frequently—they’re also becoming more severe. Modern vehicles have advanced technology and expensive parts, making repairs more costly. Additionally, higher speeds and riskier driving behaviors contribute to more totaled vehicles and serious injuries.


5. Increased Litigation in Auto Accidents

The legal landscape around auto accidents has shifted. More people are suing for damages, and settlements have become larger. Increased litigation raises the overall cost of claims, which insurance companies pass down to policyholders in the form of higher premiums.


6. Rising Medical Costs

Healthcare costs continue to skyrocket, and that includes medical expenses from car accident injuries. As hospitals and doctors charge more for treatments, insurance companies must cover larger payouts for injury claims, leading to higher auto insurance rates.


7. Labor Costs for Vehicle Repairs Keep Going Up

Auto repair shops are experiencing a shortage of skilled mechanics, which has led to rising labor costs. As a result, the price of fixing even minor damages has significantly increased, adding pressure to insurance companies to raise premiums.


8. Rental Car Price Increases & Low Rental Inventory

If your car is damaged in an accident and needs repairs, you might need a rental. Unfortunately, rental car prices have gone up, and there’s also a shortage of available rental vehicles. This means insurance companies are paying more for rental reimbursements, which ultimately contributes to higher premiums for everyone.


9. Used and New Car Prices Continue to Rise

Car prices have soared in recent years due to supply chain disruptions, inflation, and increased demand. Whether it’s a new or used car, replacing a totaled vehicle now costs more than ever before. This means insurance companies are paying out higher claim amounts, which results in higher premiums for policyholders.


What This Means for You

Insurance companies are adjusting their rates to keep up with rising costs across the board. While it may feel frustrating, understanding these factors can help you plan ahead. Here are a few tips to help manage your auto insurance costs:

  • Review Your Policy: Ensure you’re only paying for the coverage you need.
  • Ask About Discounts: Many insurers offer discounts for safe driving, bundling policies, or installing anti-theft devices.
  • Increase Your Deductible: A higher deductible can lower your monthly premium, but be sure you can afford the out-of-pocket cost if you have to file a claim.
  • Compare Rates: If your renewal comes with a big increase, shop around to see if another provider offers a better deal.


Sources & Additional Reading:

📄 Industry Report: LinkedIn PDF
📈
Market Trends: Hartford Insurance Auto Report


Auto insurance rates aren’t going down anytime soon, but by staying informed, you can make smarter decisions about your coverage.


Have questions about your auto insurance? Contact us to review your policy!

Contact Us

What Is Commercial Umbrella Insurance And Why Is It Important?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 19, 2025
Commercial umbrella insurance provides extra liability protection when a major claim exceeds your primary policy limits. Learn what it covers, how it works, who needs it, and why it’s becoming more essential for Michigan businesses.
How Much Does Liquor Liability Insurance Cost In Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 18, 2025
Liquor liability insurance is required for Michigan businesses with a liquor license. Learn what it covers, the legal requirements, cost factors, and how much bars and restaurants typically pay in Michigan.
General Liability vs BOP: Main Differences? Which One You Need?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 17, 2025
General Liability vs BOP insurance explained. Learn what each policy covers, how they differ, and which one your business needs for the right protection.
What Is The Best Commercial Auto Insurance For Contractors?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 16, 2025
Contractors in Michigan need the right commercial auto insurance to protect their trucks, employees, and business. Learn which coverages contractors must have, why personal auto won’t protect you, and how to choose the best commercial auto policy for your business.
Northern Michigan Second Home Insurance: What Coverage You Need
By Bryan Gutowsky March 12, 2025
Learn how to properly insure a second home or seasonal property in Northern Michigan. This guide covers classification, replacement cost, liability limits, water backup, service line coverage, short-term rental considerations, and umbrella protection.
What Are The Rates For General Liability Insurance?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 11, 2025
What Are The Rates For General Liability Insurance? (FULL Breakdown)
The Best Business Insurance For Landscapers In Michigan
By Bryan Gutowsky March 10, 2025
Looking for the best business insurance for landscapers in Michigan? This complete guide breaks down essential coverages like general liability, commercial auto, workers compensation, inland marine, and more—so you can protect your landscaping business, employees, and equipment.
Why Is Michigan Auto Insurance So Expensive? (5 Reasons)
By Bryan Gutowsky March 7, 2025
Michigan has some of the highest auto insurance rates in the country — but why? Learn the 5 main reasons why Michigan car insurance is so expensive, including PIP coverage, the no-fault system, uninsured drivers, and more.
Does Commercial Property Insurance Cover Wind & Hail Damage?
By Bryan Gutowsky March 5, 2025
Most standard commercial property insurance policies cover wind and hail damage—but not always in the way you think. Learn how deductibles, exclusions, and roof condition impact your coverage.
Product Liability Insurance For Manufacturing Companies
By Bryan Gutowsky March 4, 2025
Learn the basics of product liability insurance for manufacturers, what it covers, and why certain industries—like food, medical, and auto parts—may need specialized coverage.
Show More