Top High Value Home Insurance Companies in Michigan (And What to Look For)

Bryan Gutowsky • June 4, 2024

Top High Value Home Insurance Companies in Michigan (And What to Look For)

If you own a high value home in Michigan—whether it’s a lakefront estate, a historic property in Birmingham, or a custom-built home in Bloomfield Hills—standard homeowners insurance might not offer the protection you need. That’s where high value home insurance comes in.


These specialized policies are designed to cover luxury homes and high net worth individuals with enhanced protection, tailored service, and coverage for unique risks.


Here are some of the top high value home insurance companies in Michigan and what to consider when choosing the right one for your needs.


1. Chubb Insurance

Chubb is often considered the Cadillac of insurance for high net worth individuals. Their Masterpiece® homeowners policy offers:

  • Guaranteed replacement cost coverage
  • Coverage for valuables like fine art, jewelry, and antiques
  • Risk consulting services to proactively protect your home
  • Exceptional claims service with a white-glove approach


Chubb is a go-to for luxury homes thanks to its comprehensive policies and longstanding reputation.


2. PURE Insurance

PURE (Privilege Underwriters Reciprocal Exchange) is another elite provider focused exclusively on high value households.


Their policies often include:

  • Full replacement cost coverage for personal property
  • Rebuilding to code after a loss
  • Identity fraud expense reimbursement
  • Coverage for high-end materials and finishes

PURE is known for its concierge-level service and proactive risk management tailored to affluent homeowners.


3. AIG Private Client Group

AIG Private Client Group offers customizable coverage for multimillion-dollar homes, with broad protection and exclusive perks.

Their coverage can include:

  • Custom rebuilding coverage with no depreciation
  • Protection for collectible items, wine, or custom fixtures
  • Worldwide personal liability
  • Access to wildfire defense and security services

If you’re looking for both protection and peace of mind, AIG is a strong contender.


4. Cincinnati Insurance

Cincinnati Insurance provides flexible, high value home insurance solutions with a strong Midwest reputation.


What sets them apart:

  • Flexible policy options for custom homes
  • Scheduled personal property protection
  • Excellent claims responsiveness
  • Strong financial ratings and regional expertise

Cincinnati Insurance is a great option for those wanting elite coverage with a more personal touch.


Tips for Choosing the Best High Value Home Insurance

When comparing providers, here are a few critical things to look for:


1. Reputation and Financial Strength

Work with a company known for stability and reliability. This ensures your insurer can handle large claims—even after widespread disasters.


2. Specialized Coverage Options

Choose an insurer that understands the unique risks of high-end homes. Look for features like guaranteed replacement cost, cash settlement options, and protection for high-value collections.


3. Claims Service

Fast, fair claims handling is essential. You don’t want to navigate red tape after a loss—especially with major repairs or rebuilding involved.


4. Personalized Customer Service

Top-tier service should include risk mitigation advice, home inspections, and a dedicated point of contact who understands your specific needs.


Final Thoughts

Insuring a high value home in Michigan requires more than just a standard policy. Whether you're protecting your estate, your art collection, or your lifestyle, choosing the right insurance provider can make all the difference.


Companies like Chubb, PURE, AIG, and Cincinnati Insurance specialize in protecting what matters most. If you're unsure which option fits best, consider working with a trusted insurance advisor who can help you compare carriers and tailor the right policy for your home.

Contact Us

Commercial Property Insurance for Different Types of Properties
By Bryan Gutowsky September 6, 2024
Learn how commercial property insurance in Michigan varies for office buildings, manufacturing facilities, retail spaces, apartment buildings, and warehouses. Understand the key risk factors that affect cost and coverage.
By Bryan Gutowsky August 10, 2025
Michigan Workers Comp Insurance 101: What Is a Return to Work Program?
Commercial Property Insurance: What Is Blanket Insurance Coverage?
By Bryan Gutowsky September 4, 2024
Blanket insurance coverage can simplify and strengthen commercial property protection by combining limits for multiple buildings or locations. Learn how it works, who it benefits, and key considerations before you buy.
Is Auto Insurance For Tesla’s More Expensive? (Hint: Yes)
By Bryan Gutowsky September 3, 2024
Tesla insurance rates are often higher than for gas-powered cars. Learn why Tesla's cost more to insure, from expensive battery replacements to specialized repair needs.
Umbrella Insurance for Commercial Property Owners-Do You Need It?
By Bryan Gutowsky September 2, 2024
Discover why umbrella insurance is a smart, affordable way for commercial property owners to add extra liability protection beyond standard coverage. Learn how it works and why it matters.
What Happens When an Employee Is Injured in an Auto Accident?
By Bryan Gutowsky September 1, 2024
Learn what happens when an employee is injured in a car accident while working in Michigan. Understand how Workers Comp, commercial auto, PIP, and Hired & Non-Owned Auto coverage work together to protect your business.
What Is Inland Marine Insurance? Michigan Commercial Insurance 101
By Bryan Gutowsky August 31, 2024
Inland marine insurance protects property in transit, contractor tools, and offsite equipment. Learn how this essential commercial coverage works for Michigan businesses.
How Much Does Commercial Property Insurance Cost in Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky August 29, 2024
Wondering how much commercial property insurance costs in Michigan in 2024? Learn what factors impact pricing and how you can reduce your premiums as a business owner.
Michigan Auto Insurance Requirements: What Coverages Are Mandatory?
By Bryan Gutowsky August 27, 2024
Learn what auto insurance coverages are required in Michigan for 2025. Understand state minimums, PIP, uninsured motorist coverage, and why higher limits may better protect you.
What Is an Incident Response Plan? Why Your Business Needs One
By Bryan Gutowsky August 26, 2024
Learn what an Incident Response Plan is, why it matters, and how it protects your business from cyber threats. Every business—big or small—needs one.
Show More