What Is An Insurance Score? And How To Improve Your Score - 4 Tips

Bryan Gutowsky • February 5, 2024

What Is an Insurance Score? And How to Improve Your Score (4 Tips)

If you’ve ever wondered why your insurance rates are what they are—even with a clean record—your insurance score might be the reason.


Since the early 1990s, insurance companies have been using insurance scores to help determine your risk as a customer. But what exactly is an insurance score, how is it calculated, and what can you do to improve it? Let’s break it down.


What Is an Insurance Score?

An insurance score is a numerical rating used by insurance companies to predict how likely you are to file a claim. It’s based on historical data and is designed to estimate your potential risk as a policyholder.


In short: the lower your risk, the better your insurance score—and usually, the better your rates.

It’s important to note that each insurance company uses its own proprietary algorithm, which means your insurance score can vary from one carrier to another. Some companies weigh the insurance score heavily when calculating your premium, while others may only consider it as one of many factors.


How Is Your Insurance Score Calculated?

Your insurance score is made up of multiple data points. While the exact formula varies, here are some of the most common factors used:


1. Credit History

Your credit history is a major factor—but this is not your actual credit score. Insurers use a specialized version that looks at patterns like timely payments, outstanding debt, and account history. Importantly, a formal credit report is never pulled, so this won't show up as a hard inquiry.


2. Driving Record

For auto insurance especially, your driving history plays a big role. Accidents, tickets, and violations can all bring your score down.


3. Insurance History

Frequent claims or gaps in coverage can hurt your score. Stability and consistency in your insurance history reflect positively.


4. Location

Where you live matters. Your city and ZIP code can influence your risk profile based on crime rates, traffic, weather patterns, and more.


5. Homeownership

Insurance companies often view homeowners as more stable and less risky than renters, which can lead to a higher insurance score.


6. Age & Gender

Whether fair or not, younger male drivers are statistically seen as higher risk, and that factors into the score—even with a perfect record.


Why Does Your Insurance Score Matter?

Insurance scores help carriers determine how much you’ll pay for coverage. A higher score often means lower premiums, while a lower score can lead to higher rates or even policy denial.

In today’s market, insurance scores are not going away—so understanding how to improve yours is key to saving money on your policy.


4 Tips to Improve Your Insurance Score

Here are four practical steps you can take to improve your insurance score:


1. Keep Your Credit in Good Standing

Make payments on time, keep balances low, and avoid opening unnecessary accounts. Even though it’s not your official credit score, your financial habits still matter.


2. Maintain a Clean Driving Record

Avoid accidents and traffic violations whenever possible. Safe driving pays off in more ways than one.


3. Don’t Let Your Insurance Policies Lapse

Even a short lapse in coverage can negatively affect your insurance score. Keep your policies active, even if you're switching carriers.


4. Limit Claims to What’s Truly Necessary

Small claims can lead to higher premiums or a lower score. When possible, cover minor losses out-of-pocket to keep your record clean.


Final Thoughts

Your insurance score plays a key role in how insurance companies assess your risk and set your rates. While you can’t control every factor, staying informed and making smart decisions can go a long way in improving your score—and ultimately saving you money.

If you have questions about how your score may be impacting your insurance costs, feel free to reach out. We’re here to help you make sense of it all.


📞 Need help reviewing your insurance options or understanding your insurance score? Contact us today—we’re happy to walk you through it.

Contact Us

What Insurance Do Contractors Need in Michigan | Basics Explained
By Bryan Gutowsky May 5, 2025
Contractor insurance in Michigan explained. Learn what coverage contractors actually need, including general liability, workers’ comp, commercial auto, inland marine, and umbrella insurance.
What Does Replacement Cost Mean for Insurance? (Simple Explanation)
By Bryan Gutowsky May 1, 2025
What does replacement cost mean in insurance? Learn how replacement cost works, how it differs from market value and actual cash value, and why it matters for homes and businesses.
How Much Commercial Auto Liability Insurance Do You Need in Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky April 30, 2025
How much commercial auto liability insurance do Michigan businesses need? Learn why $1M CSL is common, when umbrella coverage makes sense, and more.
Most Affordable General Liability Insurance - Michigan Businesses
By Bryan Gutowsky April 28, 2025
Looking for affordable general liability insurance in Michigan? Learn what it covers, what affects cost, and how to find the best value without coverage gaps.
Progressive For Commercial Auto Insurance? (Pros & Cons)
By Bryan Gutowsky April 27, 2025
Thinking about Progressive for commercial auto insurance? Learn the pros, cons, pricing, claims experience, and who Progressive is best for.
What Does Homeowners Insurance Cover in Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky April 26, 2025
Learn what homeowners insurance covers in Michigan, including dwelling, personal property, exclusions, deductibles, and optional endorsements you should consider.
Commercial Auto Insurance for Landscapers in Michigan
By Bryan Gutowsky April 25, 2025
Learn what commercial auto insurance covers for Michigan landscaping businesses, required coverages, Unlimited PIP rules, trailers, and cost factors.
What Insurance Coverages Do Small Businesses Need in Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky April 21, 2025
Learn what insurance small businesses need in Michigan, including general liability, workers comp, commercial auto, cyber liability, and more.
Do You Need “Full Coverage” Auto Insurance In Michigan? It Depends
By Bryan Gutowsky April 20, 2025
Wondering if you need full coverage auto insurance in Michigan? Learn what “full coverage” really means, what it includes, what it doesn’t, and when it makes sense.
What Is Workers Compensation Insurance For Michigan Businesses?
By Bryan Gutowsky April 19, 2025
Learn what workers compensation insurance covers in Michigan, which businesses need it, how premiums are calculated, how audits work, and why proper limits and claims handling matter.
Show More