Workers Comp vs Disability Insurance - What’s The Difference? (Michigan Commercial Insurance 101)

Bryan Gutowsky • September 11, 2024

Workers Comp vs Disability Insurance -  What’s The Difference?

Why This Comparison Matters

As a Michigan business owner, protecting your employees isn’t just the right thing to do—it’s required by law in many cases. Two types of coverage often cause confusion: workers’ compensation insurance and disability insurance. While both help employees who can’t work due to injury or illness, the circumstances they cover are very different. Let’s break it down.


What Is Workers’ Compensation Insurance?

Workers’ compensation insurance—commonly called “workers comp”—is a state-mandated coverage for most businesses in Michigan.


Here’s what it does:

  • Covers medical expenses for work-related injuries or illnesses
  • Replaces a portion of lost wages while the employee recovers
  • Provides rehabilitation benefits to help employees return to work
  • Includes disability benefits in cases of permanent injury
  • Can also cover occupational illnesses, such as lung damage from chemical exposure


In short, workers comp is all about protecting employees when something happens on the job.


What Is Disability Insurance?

Disability insurance steps in when an employee can’t work due to an injury or illness outside of work. Unlike workers comp, it’s not required by law but is often offered as part of an employee benefits package—or purchased individually.


Here’s how it works:

  • Short-Term Disability (STD): Replaces income for a few weeks or months
  • Long-Term Disability (LTD): Provides income replacement for much longer—sometimes until retirement, depending on the policy
  • Covers everyday accidents or illnesses, such as a skiing injury or a serious medical condition


Importantly, disability insurance does not cover medical bills—it’s focused on replacing lost income.


Key Differences Between Workers Comp & Disability Insurance

The easiest way to think about the difference is this: workers’ compensation covers injuries or illnesses that happen on the job, while disability insurance covers those that happen off the job.


Workers comp pays for medical expenses and a portion of lost wages when the injury or illness is work-related, and in Michigan, employers are legally required to carry it in most cases.


Disability insurance, on the other hand, is focused on replacing income when an employee can’t work due to something unrelated to their job, like a skiing accident or a serious illness. It doesn’t cover medical bills, and it isn’t legally required—though it’s often offered as part of a benefits package or purchased individually.


Workers comp premiums are paid by the employer, while disability insurance can be funded by the employer, the employee, or a combination of both, depending on the plan.


Why Michigan Businesses Should Understand Both

The main point of confusion comes down to where the injury or illness happens.

  • If it’s on the job → workers comp.
  • If it’s off the job → disability insurance.


One isn’t a substitute for the other. Together, they create a safety net that ensures employees are financially supported whether something happens at work or on their own time.


For employers, workers comp ensures compliance with Michigan law and protects your business from lawsuits related to workplace injuries. Offering disability insurance on top of that shows employees you value their well-being beyond the workplace.


Final Thoughts

To sum it up:

  • Workers comp covers on-the-job injuries and illnesses.
  • Disability insurance covers off-the-job injuries and illnesses.


Both serve critical but distinct roles in protecting employees. By understanding the difference—and offering both when possible—you can build a stronger, more secure workforce.


📞 Need help reviewing your Michigan workers comp policy or setting up the right employee benefits package? Contact us today—we’ll make sure your business and your team are fully protected.

Contact Us

How To Get High-Limit Umbrella Insurance For Contract Requirements
By Bryan Gutowsky February 4, 2025
Need $5M, $10M, or even higher umbrella insurance limits to meet contract requirements? Learn how to secure high-limit umbrella coverage for your business, why it’s often required, and how an independent agent can help you find the right policy.
Grocery Store Insurance - Everything You Need To Know
By Bryan Gutowsky February 2, 2025
Learn everything you need to know about grocery store insurance in Michigan — from property and stock coverage to general liability, workers comp, and cyber insurance. Discover which coverages protect your store, employees, and inventory.
What Is The Average Cost Of Homeowners Insurance In Michigan?
By Bryan Gutowsky January 29, 2025
Discover how much homeowners insurance costs in Michigan for 2024–2025, what drives your premium, and proven strategies to lower your rate. Get data, tips, and real examples here.
How To Lower Commercial Auto Insurance Premiums
By Bryan Gutowsky January 28, 2025
Learn how to lower your commercial auto insurance premiums in 2025 with proven strategies from Travelers, the 2nd largest commercial auto insurer in the U.S. Discover fleet safety tips, driver management strategies, and cost-saving bundling options for your business.
Best Workers Compensation Insurance For Contractors In Michigan
By Bryan Gutowsky January 27, 2025
Looking for the best workers compensation insurance for contractors in Michigan? Learn what coverage includes, how to choose the right limits, what affects your cost, and how to find the best provider for your business.
How Much Liability Insurance Does Your Business Need? (2025)
By Bryan Gutowsky January 24, 2025
Find out how much liability insurance your business really needs in 2025. Learn what general liability covers, how contracts and industry risks affect your limits, and when to add umbrella coverage for extra protection.
Builder’s Risk Insurance: What It Covers & How To Get It
By Bryan Gutowsky January 22, 2025
Learn what builder’s risk insurance covers, why contractors and property owners need it, and how to get the right policy for your construction or renovation project. Protect your materials, equipment, and structure during construction.
What Is Umbrella Insurance And Do I Need It?
By Bryan Gutowsky January 20, 2025
Learn what umbrella insurance is, how it works, and why it’s one of the smartest ways to protect your assets and future earnings. Discover coverage limits, eligibility requirements, and average costs in this complete guide.
General Liability Insurance for Manufacturers Explained
By Bryan Gutowsky January 16, 2025
Learn what general liability insurance covers for manufacturers, how costs are calculated, and what exclusions to watch for to protect your business.
Hired & Non-Owned Auto Insurance: What You Need & How To Get It
By Bryan Gutowsky January 9, 2025
Learn what Hired and Non-Owned Auto Insurance (HNOA) covers and why Michigan businesses need it. Discover how this affordable coverage protects your company when employees use personal or rented vehicles for work.
Show More