How Much Does Commercial Auto Insurance For Contractors Cost? (& Ways To Save)

Bryan Gutowsky • December 8, 2024

How Much Does Commercial Auto Insurance For Contractors Cost? (& Ways To Save)

When you’re a contractor in Michigan, your vehicles are more than just transportation—they’re essential tools that keep your business moving. Whether you run a single pickup truck or a fleet of dump trucks, having the right commercial auto insurance in place is critical. But how much does it actually cost, and what can you do to keep those premiums under control?


Let’s break it down.


Key Factors That Affect Contractor Commercial Auto Insurance Costs

  • Type of Vehicle & How It’s Used
    A dump truck hauling heavy loads will cost significantly more to insure than a car used for sales or estimates. Larger, heavier vehicles carry greater risk, which is reflected in higher premiums.
  • Employee Driving Records
    Your drivers’ Motor Vehicle Records (MVRs) are a big deal. Employees with clean records help keep premiums lower. Accidents and violations drive rates up. Running MVR checks before handing over the keys is one of the simplest ways to manage risk.
  • Fleet Size
    The more vehicles on the road, the greater your exposure to accidents. Managing a fleet properly—through safety programs, maintenance schedules, and monitoring driver performance—can help keep costs in check.
  • Claims History
    If your business has a history of frequent or severe claims, insurance companies see you as a higher risk. Maintaining a clean claims record through safety and proactive maintenance directly impacts your costs.


Average Cost of Commercial Auto Insurance for Contractors

Because every business is different, costs can vary widely. But here are some ballpark ranges for Michigan contractors:

  • Light-use vehicles (pickups, small vans): $1,500 – $2,500 per year, per vehicle
  • Medium-use vehicles (larger work trucks, trailers): $2,500 – $5,000 per year
  • Heavy-duty vehicles (dump trucks, specialized equipment haulers): $5,000+ per year


Ways Contractors Can Save on Commercial Auto Insurance

  • Regular Maintenance – Well-maintained vehicles reduce accidents and claims.
  • Run Employee Driving Checks – Only put safe drivers behind the wheel.
  • Fleet Safety Programs – Implement policies for distracted driving, safe loading, and road safety training.
  • Bundle Policies – Combine your commercial auto with general liability or workers’ compensation for discounts.
  • Higher Deductibles – Opt for higher deductibles on physical damage coverage if you’re comfortable with the out-of-pocket risk.


Final Thoughts

Commercial auto insurance is one of the biggest expenses for contractors, but it’s also one of the most important. The right coverage not only protects your vehicles but also shields your business from major financial loss. By understanding the factors that affect cost and taking steps to reduce risk, you can get the coverage you need at a price that makes sense for your business.


📞 If you’re a contractor in Michigan and want help reviewing your commercial auto insurance, reach out today. The right plan could save you thousands while protecting your business from unexpected losses.

Contact Us

ADP For Workers Comp Insurance - Pro’s & Con’s (Honest Review)
By Bryan Gutowsky December 5, 2024
Thinking about using ADP for workers comp insurance? Read our honest review of the pros, cons, and best alternatives so you can decide if it’s the right fit for your business.
Most Affordable Electric Vehicle Insurance Companies In Michigan
By Bryan Gutowsky December 4, 2024
Looking for affordable electric vehicle insurance in Michigan? Learn why EV coverage costs more, which companies offer the best rates, and tips to lower your premium with bundling, deductibles, and smart coverage options.
My Business Insurance Was Non-Renewed - What Should I Do?
By Bryan Gutowsky December 3, 2024
Has your business insurance policy been non-renewed? Learn why this happens, the steps you should take, and how to find replacement coverage in 2025.
‘Combined Single Limit’ (CSL) For Commercial Auto Insurance
By Bryan Gutowsky December 2, 2024
Learn what Combined Single Limit (CSL) means in a commercial auto insurance policy. Discover how CSL coverage works, why businesses choose it, and how it compares to split limits.
How Much Does Workers Comp Insurance For Contractors Cost?
By Bryan Gutowsky December 1, 2024
Learn how much workers’ comp insurance costs for contractors in Michigan. Discover the key factors—like payroll, job classification, safety programs, and audits—that impact your premium.
How to Calculate Commercial Property Insurance Coverage
By Bryan Gutowsky November 29, 2024
Learn how to determine the right amount of insurance coverage for a commercial property. Understand replacement cost, market value, building codes, inflation, and key factors that impact your policy limits.
Is General Liability Insurance Required By Law?
By Bryan Gutowsky November 26, 2024
Is general liability insurance required by law? Learn when it’s required, why landlords, lenders, and contracts often demand it, and why every business should consider coverage.
Why Is Commercial Auto Insurance So Expensive? (What You Can Do)
By Bryan Gutowsky November 25, 2024
Discover why commercial auto insurance rates are rising in 2025 and what your business can do to manage costs. Learn about claims, repair expenses, lawsuits, and smart strategies to save money.
Umbrella Insurance For Contractors In Michigan: Why It’s Essential
By Bryan Gutowsky November 24, 2024
Discover why umbrella insurance is essential for contractors in Michigan. Learn how it protects against large claims, covers legal defense costs, and helps you meet contract requirements affordably.
Best Small Business Insurance Companies In Michigan
By Bryan Gutowsky November 23, 2024
Discover the best small business insurance companies in Michigan. Learn which carriers are top-rated, what coverages to look for, and how an independent agent can help you find the right policy at the best value.
Show More